Saturday, August 21, 2010

Big Ten Divisions: The mistake the Big Ten shouldn't make

Back in June, great excitement surrounded Nebraska’s agreement to join the Big Ten Conference. The Big Ten got one of the “blue bloods” in college football, within the Big Ten’s traditional Midwestern footprint, with one of the best, most knowledgeable fan bases in the country. It was consistent with the Big Ten’s “we do things different here” mentality: while much of the country expected the Big Ten to poach Texas or possibly add Rutgers. Chasing after Texan population growth or Rutgers as an entrée into the New York media market (and Big Ten Network carriage fees) was considered a given. The Big Ten’s decision to take Nebraska instead was seemingly consistent with a league that holds out for only academically elite schools and has staunchly opposed a college football playoff, preferring instead the Rose Bowl and the relationship with the Pacific-10 Conference.

One of the givens when Nebraska joined was that, with 12 members, the Big Ten would hold a conference championship game. The NCAA generally requires that member schools schedule no more than 12 Football contests per season. However, there are series of so-called “exempt” games, which don’t count against the 12-game limit. The most famous, of course, is a bowl game, but for our purposes we’re more interested in the “Conference Championship Game.” The rule allows leagues consisting of at least 12 members to split into 2 divisions of at least 6 members each, and play “round robin” competition within each division (although leagues usually also schedule a few games across the divisions). If a league complies with these rules, then the 2 Division Champions may play in a Conference Championship Game that does not count against the 12-game limit. Ever since Roy Kramer discovered this rule in the early 90s and his Southeastern Conference’s title game became a smash hit, it has been an on-again, off-again (but mostly on-again) trend in college football for leagues to get to 12 members and hold a nationally televised title game.

Almost from the day that Nebraska announced that they had joined, there was speculation about how the divisions would be drawn up. Some factions have said from the beginning that the easiest and most logical arrangement for the Big Ten would be a simple East/West split, with the following divisions:

East: Penn State, Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, Indiana, Purdue

West: Northwestern, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska

Immediately after Nebraska joined, Commissioner Jim Delany said that the league would have 3 “priorities,” in the following order: (a) “competitive fairness” (b) “maintenance of rivalries” and (c) “geography.” The emphasis on competitive fairness was thought by many to be a reference to splitting the so-called “Big Four” of Ohio State, Nebraska, Michigan, and Penn State evenly into the 2 divisions (2 and 2) – obviously a deviation from a simple East/West geographic model. This sense was generally thought to have been confirmed when Wisconsin Athletic Director Barry Alvarez was quoted as making statements along these same lines (although the careful reader will note some ambiguity). Although Alvarez was later quoted as reframing the analysis from splitting a “Big 4” to splitting a “Big 6” (including Wisconsin and Iowa), Commissioner Delany later poured further cold water on the possibility of a geographic alignment.

In recent days, further specifics have come out that make it clearer and clearer that the Big Ten has lost its way in drawing up the divisions. Most proposals for divisions have placed Michigan and Ohio State in the same division, on the theory that the best way for their traditional season-ending game to be emulated in the new era of a divisional league format is for them to be placed in the same division, with (assuming Michigan’s program rebounds) the division title and an appearance in the Conference Championship Game on the line in many seasons. However, news recently broke that OSU Athletic Director Gene Smith had suggested that they might actually be split; shortly thereafter, Michigan AD Dave Brandon stated much more specifically that it was likely to happen, and as of this writing it is considered all but a certainty.

Why does this matter to Michigan State? My position is that, whatever our feelings about Michigan, the tradition of the Michigan/Ohio State rivalry is a treasure that belongs to the entire Big Ten. What differentiates the Big Ten from much of the rest of the country is the way our league cherishes traditions – particularly traditions that matter. If we stand idly by and watch the Big Ten sell its soul in a misguided pursuit of a few extra TV nickels, it might be something that affects Michigan State next time. Besides that, there is every reason to believe that this effort will fail: an enormous part of the Big Ten’s brand identity is tied up in the notion that we aren’t the kind of place where we kowtow to TV demands. The Big Ten sat on 11 members for nearly 20 years, when going to 12 would have produced a lucrative championship game. The league has staunchly opposed a playoff, which would be more profitable than the bowl system, because it prefers the tradition of the relationship with the Rose Bowl and Pac-10. (Note: I prefer a playoff, but not because it would be more profitable, and I respect the Big Ten’s willingness to elevate tradition above money.) The Big Ten has refused to play on weeknights and places fairly strict limits on playing Saturday night games in the cold weeks of late Fall, even though making concessions on either point would likely be profitable and certainly would provide for more nationally televised games and greater exposure. The league currently utilizes an “unbalanced” schedule which protects traditional rivalry games over balance; thus Ohio State never loses two of the very good teams (Michigan and Penn State), Penn State never misses one very good team and one middle class team (Ohio State and Michigan State), but Wisconsin never misses only a pretty good team and a crummy team (Iowa and Minnesota). And that’s a good thing, I say: better to preserve those traditions and tolerate a little scheduling imbalance than eviscerate what makes college football special. Thus I am all the more shocked and saddened by the Big Ten’s apparent direction here.

It is worthwhile to take an aside here and address the point that was raised by President Graham Spanier of Penn State. He seems to feel that, so long as 2 rivals play annually, that is enough. But what makes a rivalry sizzle in most cases is jockeying for position in the standings against each other. The only way to do that is if the teams are both in the same division. That way, only one can finish in 1st place, and there’s more on the line when the game is played than mere bragging rights. I find it absurd and baffling that so many of the powers that be seem to think that, just because two teams play annually, that’s an adequate compromise. Unless they’re both in the same division, playing for the same title, and jockeying for position in the same standings, I fail to see what makes the rivalry really sizzle. I would argue that the Michigan/Ohio State rivalry became what it did because of the “Big 2, Little 8” Bo & Woody era, when so often their season-ending game had the league title on the line. Is there any doubt that it would not have become the same phenomenon if that hadn’t been such a routine situation?

What the Big Ten should do is use the geographic divisions. There are many reasons why. Some believe that geography per se is a sufficient reason to group the teams – a position I sympathize with. Ultimately, I think the Big Ten should use geographic divisions, although for non-geographic reasons (but referring to the alignment as the “geographic model” is a convenient shorthand). I reach that outcome by applying the following 4 rules:

1. Ohio State and Nebraska should not be in the same division. They’re the two most successful programs in the league (now that Nebraska is joining).

2. Ohio State and Michigan must be in the same division, for the reasons stated above.

3. Michigan and Michigan State must be in the same division, again for the reasons stated above.

4. Wisconsin, Iowa, and Minnesota must be in a division together. The Big Ten has always been a league that depends on collegiality and treating the membership as fundamentally equal, even if this is not the practical reality; I consider it an important test of the Big Ten’s commitment to this principle that Minnesota’s traditional rivalries with Iowa and Wisconsin be honored, even if Minnesota’s program has not enjoyed the success of the league’s elites.

This produces two pairs of 3 teams each:

A: Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State

B: Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota

Because of the first rule, there are only two options for what to do with Nebraska. The first is to combine these two groups of 3 teams, and then have the other 6 teams form a division. Thus:

A: Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota

B: Nebraska, Penn State, Illinois, Northwestern, Indiana, Purdue

I consider this alignment laughably unbalanced; even if we cannot measure balance precisely, we can ask that it at least pass a smell test. As a result, we have to take the only other option for Nebraska, which is to put it with the triad of Plains States teams to form a quartet. Thus:

A: Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State

B: Nebraska, Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota

The next central question is what to do with Penn State. It’s been suggested that putting Ohio State, Penn State, and Michigan in the same division would be “unbalanced” or “stacked.” So let’s assume that we separate Penn State from those other 2.

A′′: Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, [Purdue], [Illinois], [Northwestern]

B′′: Nebraska, Penn State, Wisconsin, Iowa, Minnesota, [Indiana]

The teams in brackets can be moved around interchangeably within these rules. I selected Indiana because it is pretty clearly the weakest team in the Big Ten. Yet even with Indiana in the B′′ group, it seems (once again) not to pass the balance smell test. Nebraska, Penn State, Wisconsin, and Iowa all in the same group seems like an unfair slugfest to me – particularly given the clouds surrounding Michigan’s program. At least in the near-term, this alignment might as well be a bye for Ohio State into the championship game. As a result, it strikes me that the only logical thing to do is to put Penn State with Michigan State et al. Thus:

A: Penn State, Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State

B: Nebraska, Minnesota, Iowa, Wisconsin

Once you have arrived at this alignment, all of the controversial decisions have been made. At this point, we’re left with 4 teams: Northwestern, Illinois, Indiana, and Purdue. These 4 teams logically can (and should) be split into 2 pairs of in-state rivals. Although the Illinois pair could be put with the “East” teams and the Indiana pair with the “West” teams consistent with these rules, what would be the point? Does anybody seriously believe that this would substantially affect the league’s competitive “balance”? I doubt it, and at this point (given the results of the process outlined here for making the controversial decisions) the only reason to deviate from assigning these 2 pairs east/west geographically would be to somehow assert our independence from geography (or as I like to say, change for change’s sake).

But we can talk about this all day. I, for one, intend to do what little I can about this situation, which I consider an unmitigated disaster for the Big Ten. We should be writing to the powers that be in the Big Ten. Consider dropping a letter or e-mail to some of the following individuals if you agree with me and want to express your displeasure:

Mr. James E. Delany


Commissioner, Big Ten Conference


1500 Higgins Road


Park Ridge, IL 60068-6300

jdelany@bigten.org

Dr. Michael A. McRobbie, Chair

Council of Presidents/Chancellors, Big Ten Conference

200 Bryan Hall

107 S. Indiana Avenue

Bloomington, IN 47405-7000

iupres@indiana.edu

Dr. Lou Anna K. Simon

President, Michigan State University

450 Administration Building

East Lansing, MI 48824-1046

presmail@msu.edu

Mr. Mark J. Hollis, Director

Department of Intercollegiate Athletics, Michigan State University

218 Jenison Fieldhouse

East Lansing, MI 48824-1025

hollis@ath.msu.edu

Mr. Joel I. Ferguson, Chair

Board of Trustees, Michigan State University

1223 Turner Street, Ste. 300

Lansing, MI 48906-4363

lucyjif@aol.com

Ms. Julia D. Darlow, Chair

Board of Regents, University of Michigan

P.O. Box 130047

Ann Arbor, MI 48113-0047

jdarlow@umich.edu

As near as I can tell, these are the people who answer to us, as Spartan students, alumni, and fans, who are in a position to do something about this mess. (Although Ms. Darlow is the Chair of the Michigan Regents, she’s elected, so if you’re a Michigan resident, she actually answers to you whether or not you’re associated with the University.) If we speak out, who knows – they might even listen to us. What’s more, they might actually do something about it.

58 comments:

  1. The other thing that chafes me about this is that splitting OSU and UM is obviously intended to produce an OSU/UM rematch in the championship game. There's something I find inherently distasteful about gerrymandering the divisions to produce a rematch, and I find it particularly distasteful when it's these two teams that they're doing it for. It is the rare sort of act that is both disrespectful to the league's traditions AND disrespectful to the other members in the league, whose rivalries apparently are not important enough to gerrymander the divisions to produce a rematch. Are the rest of us chopped liver?

    ReplyDelete
  2. The funny thing about Adam's point is that the ACC basically tried to do the same thing with Miami and Florida State when they split their divisions in 2005. Since then, only once has either of them even made the title game and instead Virginia Tech has made it the most often. Set the divisions geographically and things will work themselves out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Even though it probably won't happen, as a Gophers fan in Mpls, I'm salivating at seeing a division that includes the Gophers with UM, MSU, OSU, WI & IA. Those are must-see games on the schedule every year and could help with recruiting knowing the team gets to visit the Big House & the Horseshoe every couple years.

    Very well-thought out. Since you fixed this, how about the playoff next? I have my own thoughts on that (16 teams). Too long to get into here.

    ReplyDelete
  4. In my mind, Matt, a division that had Wisconsin, Iowa, and Nebraska, with a protected inter-divisional game against Michigan, would be just as attractive, no?

    You can write to your school's leadership as follows:
    Dr. Robert H. Bruininks
    President, University of Minnesota
    202 Morrill Hall
    100 Church Street S.E.
    Minneapolis, MN 55455-0110
    upres@umn.edu

    Mr. Joel Maturi
    Director of Athletics, University of Minnesota
    516 15th Avenue S.E.
    Minneapolis, MN 55455-0130
    icaadmin@umn.edu

    Mr. Clyde E. Allen, Jr., Chair
    Board of Regents, University of Minnesota
    600 McNamara Alumni Center
    200 Oak Street S.E.
    Minneapolis, MN 55455-2020
    allen190@umn.edu

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think you're letting your bias show through a little with this statement:
    "Penn State never misses one very good team and one middle class team (Ohio State and Michigan State), but Wisconsin never misses only a pretty good team and a crummy team (Iowa and Minnesota)."

    By all metrics, Michigan State and Minnesota are comparable and by most estimates, Michigan State is worse, especially since the Gophers beat MSU in 2009, 42-34. (Although it would be fair to count both as "crummy" teams.)

    Counting from 2000 (rankings are AP Poll/Coaches poll):
    2000 - Minn - 6-6 (bowl loss to NC State), MSU 5-6 (no bowl).
    2001 - Minn - 4-7, beat MSU 28-19, MSU - 7-5 (bowl win over Fresno State)
    2002 - Minn - 8-5 (bowl win over Arkansas); MSU - 4-8 (no bowl)
    2003 - Minn - 10-3, ranked 20/17 (bowl win over Oregon); MSU - 8-5 (bowl loss to Nebraska)
    2004 - Minn - 7-5, (bowl win over Alabama); MSU - 5-7 (bowl loss to Hawaii)
    2005 - Minn - 7-5, (bowl loss to Virginia); MSU - 5-6
    2006 - Minn - 6-7; (bowl loss to Texas Tech); MSU (4-8, no bowl, one conference win, set the record for the greatest comeback from a deficit in college football in getting that one win.)
    2007 - Minn - 1-11 (no conference victories, worst season on this list for both teams); MSU - 7-6 (bowl loss to Boston College).
    2008 - Minn - 7-6 (bowl loss to Kansas, Minn ranked highest 20 during year); MSU - 9-4 ranked 24/24 (bowl loss to Georgia, ranked highest 17/15 during year).
    2009 - Minn - 6-7 (bowl loss to Iowa State); MSU - 6-7 (bowl loss to Texas Tech).

    Other notable matchups: MSU blew out Gophers in 2004, 51-17; but Minn returned the favor in 2005 with a 41-18 victory.
    Gophers: six national championships, 18 Big Ten championships. MSU: six national championships, six Big Ten championships.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I don't consider all-time results relevant. Nothing that happened before about 1990 matters all that much. In recent decades, scholarship limitations have evened the playing field, and the universal availability of games on television has made recruiting a more democratic process. Historic league and national championships make the fans proud and keep them coming back for more, but have nothing to do with what the competitive dynamics are like today.

    Since 1993, when Penn State joined the league (and the point from whence most of the statistics have been aggregated), Minnesota has 44 league wins to MSU's 63. That's a clear trend. Minnesota has been more aggressive in scheduling I-AA/I-FCS teams than MSU (we just played our first-ever I-FCS team last year) so I don't know that overall records are a very good way of comparing the teams.

    ReplyDelete
  7. When I wrote that, I had the following tiers in mind:
    Very Good: Ohio State (106 wins), Nebraska (98 Big 8/12 wins), Michigan (94), Penn State (86)
    Pretty Good: Wisconsin (79), Iowa (71)
    Middle Class: Purdue (63), Michigan State (63), Northwestern (59)
    Crummy: Illinois (45), Minnesota (44), Indiana (33)

    ReplyDelete
  8. http://www.vcstar.com/news/2010/aug/21/breaking-from-tradition/

    Pac-10 Commissioner: “My bias is for coming up for something that’s easy to understand for fans. I want an easy narrative to follow and it’s important that we have competitive equilibrium. Those are the two things I’m going to emphasize.”

    Why does the Big Ten place no value on "something that's easy to understand for fans" and "an easy narrative to follow"?

    ReplyDelete
  9. The Big 12 also tried this with trying to produce Oklahoma/Nebraska title games. It didn't work. Maybe Tom Osbourne can talk some sense into David Brandon and explain to him the difference between college football and selling crappy pizza.

    ReplyDelete
  10. purposes best and does Cla Safflower Oil no longer constitute scientific advice, and isn't a replacement for hospital therapy or recommendation given by physicians or educated scientific personnel. Please evaluate the complete.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/cla-safflower-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Which helps create quick outcomes Biogenic Xr On the off chance that you need to Get Stronger Erections look at additional on the Most Powerful and.
    http://www.healthprograme.com/biogenic-xr-reviews/

    ReplyDelete
  12. the best element is there are lots Biogenic XR of numerous ways to end your premature ejaculation troubles, both as a transient solution or a permanent treatment. right here are a number of the many stuff you could do:
    http://xtrfact.com/biogenic-xr-uk/

    ReplyDelete
  13. The body to utilize oxygen and Cla Safflower Oil fat to fuel the activity The low power zone is the place your heart rate is at roughly % of your.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/cla-safflower-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  14. The pubic location right have a Testro T3 been the attaches to the frame, so it does have interaction the ligament simply positioned, a traction tool works.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/testro-t3-uk/

    ReplyDelete
  15. There are elective home grown Testx Core arrangements, and additionally needle therapy But the most well-known medicines are directing and natural medications.
    http://www.usadrugguide.com/testx-core-review/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Mesoestetic, you can return your Perlelux skin to the manner it become before solar publicity and life in popular took its toll.
    http://www.usadrugguide.com/perlelux-ca/

    ReplyDelete
  17. The healthy eating plan regulate Vedda Blood Sugar Remedy the medication in step with the alteration within the healthy diet weight-reduction plan exercising regularly
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/vedda-blood-sugar-remedy/

    ReplyDelete
  18. You can lose a considerable measure CLA Safflower Oilof weight. Snap interface underneath to realize what else you need to factor in eating routine designs.
    http://xtrfact.com/cla-safflower-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  19. For 12 entire hours previously eating CLA Safflower Oil a dinner You can build your fasting period later as you proceed with the program.
    http://xtrfact.com/cla-safflower-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  20. When we age, the creation of these two Dermagen IQ proteins starts to go low and thus the skin begins ending up free and loose, and at last winds up growing scarce differences Dermagen IQ for UK and wrinkles everywhere on its surface.
    http://www.usadrugguide.com/dermagen-iq/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Layers moves toward becoming Dermagen IQ lower, with age, because of the action of a catalyst called hyaluronidaise.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/dermagen-iq/

    ReplyDelete
  22. But without the hormone Rapiture Muscle Builder manipulation which is constantly a volatile thing Rapiture Muscle for Spain You don't want to play around along with your hormones.
    http://xtrfact.com/rapiture-muscle-builder/

    ReplyDelete
  23. Perlelux Items is known to trigger hypersensitivities. It can likewise influence you mentally as it will change your state of mind.
    http://www.drozhelp.com/perlelux/

    ReplyDelete
  24. D BAL Max Dropping those ultimate 15 lbs of fats or gaining those 20 lbs of lean muscle Drumroll please The secret is to keep.
    http://xtrfact.com/d-bal-max-review/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Xtrfact Advantage coordination. The arrangement may uncover wellbeing data to the degree approved by and to the degree.
    http://xtrfact.com/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Pure CBD Oil on the planet aside from people and the creatures they keep. It's a definitive fast food eat less - simply pick and go.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/pure-cbd-oil/

    ReplyDelete
  27. Dermagen IQ To discover where you can purchase totally sheltered and exceptionally successful common healthy Dermagen IQ for UK skin items that .
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/dermagen-iq/

    ReplyDelete
  28. Nitridex For me, the exceptional method with the aid of a ways is the herbal enhancement approach And that i say this advisedly.
    http://supplementdigestdog.com/nitridex/

    ReplyDelete
  29. Zylix Plus significant experiences into powerful normal methods for curing certain indications of fruitlessness Sound Diet.
    http://www.drozhealthblog.com/zylix-plus/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Hi. I discovered your website utilizing msn. This is a to a great degree elegantly composed article. I will make sure to bookmark it and come back to peruse a greater amount of your helpful data. A debt of gratitude is in order for the post. I'll absolutely rebound. Movierulz

    ReplyDelete
  31. I as of late discovered numerous helpful data in your site particularly this website page. Among the heaps of remarks on your articles. Much obliged for sharing.
    When Jenny Wren Was Young Nursery Rhyme Lyrics

    ReplyDelete
  32. I respect what you have done here. I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back however I would expect by every one of the remarks this is working for you also.
    Top Technology Trends of 2018

    ReplyDelete
  33. Increased Stomach Acid Levels
    Rapid Tone Weight Loss may increase the amount of acid in your stomach. This may cause side effects of nausea, heartburn and indigestion. Such side effects are particularly dangerous for people with pre-existing gastrointestinal health issues, such as a stomach ulcer. Consequently, don't take this supplement if you have a stomach ulcer, the University of Michigan Health System advises.
    Drug Interactions
    Consult your medical provider about all medications you're taking before beginning treatment with Rapid Tone Weight Loss. Concomitant use of Rapid Tone Weight Loss and prescription blood-thinners may increase your risk of developing bleeding complications. Additionally, avoid taking Rapid Tone Weight Loss in conjunction with antihypertensives, warns Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. The combination of this supplement and antihypertensives may result in a significant decrease in your blood pressure.
    https://supplementch3mistry.wordpress.com/2018/06/27/rapid-tone-diet/

    ReplyDelete
  34. Or you can eat boiled carrots or otherreview purefitketo vegetables, such as kleçatka additional bonus.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Diet Plan Forskolin
    It is unendingly suitable not to surpass the suggested estimates.
    intestinal shortcoming go to probiotics!
    For quite a while, ineffectiveness swarms ... In inclusion, created some prosperity nutrition side, and your gut appears to have a little tangle to extract. To improve tone to your journey, can a course of probiotics to be productive?
    Touted for a reasonable time, probiotics have the breeze in their sails.
    https://dietplanforskolin.com/

    ReplyDelete
  36. I eat five situations a full day, I eat healthy stuff rapid tone benefits, therefore i avoid fat things, sweet drinks, I think I've a balanced diet plan.

    ReplyDelete
  37. It helps get rid of fat for energy rather than intermittent fasting ketocarbs also, just like the traditional diet schemes.

    ReplyDelete

  38. This barrier, referred to as the Blood-Human is keto safe brain Barrier also, enables it enter the mind, though it getting hydrophilic even,

    ReplyDelete

  39. Psychologist, philosopherqualia nootropic, inventor and author.

    ReplyDelete
  40. mouth|mouth area promising that this would keto x factor reviewsprevent overeating and promote health. Or, way before

    ReplyDelete
  41. Originality is the fine art of remembering what you hear but forgetting where you heard it. Click here

    ReplyDelete
  42. Try not to give joint torment a chance to overwhelm you. Quit languishing and pick over Proflexoral Pills to state farewell to firmness and inconvenience forever. Bring your life on track and receive astounding rewards from the fantastic item.
    Click here to read more about Proflexoral

    ReplyDelete
  43. Kinky Lash Extension You can in like way utilize this serum on your eye-foreheads. Clean your eye-foreheads and after that utilization it to the association of your eye-temples. Give it some place in all the distinctive to have the capacity to get eat into your epidermis viewpoint.

    These females did not get enough of compliments they are getting now as often as possible at whatever angle they swell their eyelash. Examined their tribute underneath to know their experience

    Becky, 34 says "I am so subject to Kinky Lash that I for the most part keep this in my sack at whatever viewpoint I go outside. I used to execute counterfeit eyelash anyway then I foreseen to unendingly increment over that it may mishap off yet since I have begun utilizing this my eyelash are getting more extensive and Kinky Lash"

    Chole, 35 gives "I have been inclining toward Kinky Lash so much that I have besides talented this to my amigos who used to depend on upon the eyelash moves forward. It respects the point that prior I used to have thin eyelash anyway in the wake up of utilizing this serum I have another prosecution since it helped my eyelash to make"

    https://www.smore.com/wmg3b-kinky-lash-vs-false-eyelashes
    Read Our Most Rated Bone + oak Forskolin Reviews Weight Loss Supplement https://www.smore.com/tzuyv-bone-oak-forskolin-reviews-scam

    ReplyDelete
  44. PureFit Keto Reviews What are the advantages of Naturnice Keto Power?

    Improves the processing of the human body

    Incorporates characteristic fixings

    PureFit Keto Shark Tank Melts the fat cells to make you thin and trim

    Ousting of the additional loss from the body

    Demonstrated and viable results

    Faults Contains a pea measure of caffeine that can prompt uncommon reactions

    Costly to purchase

    https://www.smore.com/za48x-purefit-keto-diet-reviews-uk-canada
    https://ketorapidtone.com/testo-drive-365-canada/

    ReplyDelete
  45. keto fiber supplement the experiment drawing to a close and obvious positive changes to my outward appearance I began to wonder what might be happening on the inside. So I headed to my GP for a check up. prepared keto meals low carb fiber supplement
    https://www.smore.com/e0jgk-keto-ultra-diet-reviews-shark-tank

    ReplyDelete
  46. Pure Slim Keto
    Fixings

    It include 100% every single ordinary adjusting and It contains HCA(hydroxycitric damaging), which causes in decreasing load to aggregate things up timeframe. It is the typical enhancement that works think about and perform two points of confinement initially is it decline load in a word time portion and the other is it kill oil choice framework by gathering fat stores. It likewise strengthen body's handling structure to reinforce general instrument of the body. It makes your body incline and gets your body fit as a fiddle. It incorporate 100% each trademark settling and It contains HCA (hydroxy citrus remove), which helps in diminishing load in brief timeframe. It is the normal enhancement that works consider and perform two cutoff points initially is it lessen load to whole things up timeframe and the other is it dismiss oil choice technique by relaxing fat stores. It in like way connect with body's ingestion structure to general instrument of the body. It makes your body incline and gets your body fit as a fiddle.

    https://ketorapidtone.com/pure-slim-keto/

    ReplyDelete
  47. lets face it gentlemen ladies usually know a lot more about what foods to eat to shed weight and how to slim down quick. You ask a man to make low fat meals for themselves and he usually gets this deer-in the headlamp look on his face. The great thing about Nutrisystem for males is that its virtually all done for you. All you need to do is prepare the meals in accordance with the instructions and add in a few vegetarianism, fruits or buns on the way simple.

    click here

    ReplyDelete
  48. Purefit Keto Diet Plan

    make-upmakeup:

    this is an remarkable object and that i profited a sizeable measure from it. There wasn't an oz of fat and i applied Purefit Keto diet regime just for four months. I ate legitimately and strongly and completed a substantial measure of activities. This all guaranteed i have a thin and conditioned frame for pretty a while.

    Purefit Keto healthy eating plan given me all what i was reducing for from long time, a thin and trim bodily b6fd8d88d79ed1018df623d0b49e84e7 had turned into my delusion before I idea round Purefit Keto healthy dietweight-reduction plan.



    https://purefitketodietplan.com/

    ReplyDelete
  49. The Ketozol Diet is a natural dietary supplement that’s geared towards helping us with weight loss. When taken on a regular basis, it could potentially boost our metabolism and help us achieve the state of ketosis more quickly. This means that we won’t be subjected to the negative initial effects of the keto diet quite as much.

    Ketozol Review

    ReplyDelete
  50. supplementshopes
    Suicide represents approximately 1 demise in 5 among American kids and youthful grown-ups. In any case, suicide rates for youngsters in a correctional facility were a few times that rate somewhere in the range of 2000 and 2014, scientists announced.

    http://supplementshopes.com/

    ReplyDelete

  51. Instant KetoBenefits:
    Apexatropin

    Dosage:
    The dosage of many Instant Ketosupplements can vary considerably. As Froskolin Slim contains higher quality froskolin, containing 20 percent Pinnacle Garcinia Cambogia, the typical dosage range is between 25 and 60 mg in a day. Instant Ketois generally divided between two or three equal administrations. For Many users 50-60 mg is the ideal range for serious nootropic effects.

    http://supplementshopes.com/instant-keto/

    ReplyDelete



  52. 5g Male stays aware of you tossed and bowed tight until its dazzling wrapping up. Certainly worth the assessment, this liberal offense secret offers perusers to the hot and hot space of late orleans,
    https://www.pechakucha.com/presentations/5g-male-plus-male-enhancement-reviews-pills-performance-enhancer
    https://5g-male.company.site/

    ReplyDelete
  53. VCP confirmation GET SUCCESS IN YOUR VMWARE CERTIFICATION EXAMS Become a fruitful IT proficient by breezing through the famous VMware VMware dumps affirmation test. VMware confirmation is the best approach to achievement in your expert life in the IT world.

    https://sites.google.com/view/bestexamsdumpsite/vmware-dumps

    ReplyDelete
  54. Ladies are Libomax generally inactive during sexual action. goketogenics.com They loathe genital presentation and control.

    ReplyDelete