Friday, December 17, 2010

Alumni Assn warns of media bias before Izzo suspension stories are written

Update: I talked with MSUAA chief Scott Westerman, who apologized for the line in question. It has been taken down from the MSUAA's website, and he said he'd be sharing the coverage we did get with Alumni Club leaders.

Westerman's reaction is entirely appropriate. I know Scott, and he's a good guy under whose leadership the MSUAA is growing in the right direction. Kudos to him for recognizing the error and moving quickly to fix it. -DW

Original post is below.

Here's the news you probably knew by this point: Tom Izzo has been suspended for one game for a secondary violation involving hiring a guy who was in some way connected to an unnamed prospect to coach middle schoolers at a basketball camp.

Honestly? Not a big damn deal. But suspending a coach is odd, and it hasn't really been done before for something like this, and certainly not at a program like MSU. Plus, MSU has a squeaky-clean image in basketball, and it's Izzo, so that makes this a bit more newsworthy.

But that's not what caught my eye. What caught my eye was this line from an e-mail sent by the MSU Alumni Association.

"Newspapers are sold by making the worst out of every situation, and I expect
some negativity from people who would love to throw mud at us."

That line was written, I can only guess, before a single line was written in the press. And as a member of the press, I guess I take a bit of umbrage at preemptive suggestions of bias.

Well let's see if it was justified, going one-by-one through media accounts. I'll link, then summarize.

Detroit Free Press: Bias? Not really, but if there is it tilts toward MSU. Tom Izzo's point of view is given in paragraph two, a quote toward that effect is in paragraph four. In paragraphs five, six and seven, Mark Hollis says the rule is BS. The NCAA did not respond to requests for comment, so no opposing point of view is presented.

Detroit News: Bias? Can't find any. This is a short, fact-only piece that states the allegations and MSU's response. A separate link goes to a DetNews file on Izzo's career, and another links directly to MSU's statement.

Lansing State Journal: Much like the DetNews, this is a short and straightforward. Joe Rexrode's blog is the only opinion so far, and it calls shenanigans on the NCAA.

Booth Newspapers: Written by the David Mayo of the Grand Rapids Press, this one is straightforward - allegations, then MSU's response. No bias here.

ESPN: Eamon Brennan has a column up saying the rule is complex, and likely means everyone's in violation somehow. Also takes time to say Izzo has a well-deserved sterling reputation, and at no time does he question MSU's company line.

AP: States the allegations, gives MSU's line, no one from the NCAA comments. MSU comes off looking as good as possible.

The point of this exercise? Well, I couldn't find an example of bias against MSU among outlets that cover the school, or on the wire services most will use outside of the local market.

Look, I get that bashing the media is en vogue. But just as people would ask that we not rush to judgement against MSU's athletes, let me ask that our own alumni association not rush to judgement against the graduates of its own School of Journalism (like Rexrode and many of the editors and reporters at papers throughout Michigan and the USA).

And at the very least, they're owed an apology.


  1. The Russian Puppet Theater

    Ufa is the second biggest city and capital of the Russian Federation. The area which comprises Ufa is known as the "Siberian Region." The town lies in the Ufa and Belaya waterways, at the assembly of these two streams, on higher edges framing the hillforts of Ufa. It is likewise the greatest town inside the Dashnakhova locale.


    The capital of the Russian Federation, Ufa has an uncommonly heavenly mix of old and new societies. The greater part of its structures are developed out of one or the other sandstone or blocks, and the most striking quality of ufa city is the epic monolith and the flight of stairs. Other than the conspicuous indications of ufa culture - the pillar and the flight of stairs - other obvious signs of Russian inception are the monoliths in the eastern piece of town, the monoliths and the red-tiled corridors. Besides, the town brags some the best instances of local creative works. ufa

  2. You wrote this post very carefully. The amount of information is stunning and also a gainful article for us on basketball. Keep sharing this kind of articles, Thank you.youth basketball training

  3. I'm really quite sure I値l uncover many cutting edge thing there! Best of luck for those so next! สล็อต

  4. We actually such as exactly what you have obtained right here, certainly such as exactly what you are saying as well as the way in which a person state this. เล่นสล็อต

  5. เว็บหวยออนไลน์ จ่ายจริง
    ให้บริการแบบมือโปรการคลังมั่นคง จ่ายแพง ถูกจริงจ่ายจริง ไม่คดโกง พร้อมเปิดพื้นที่เล่นลอตเตอรี่มาแรงเนื่องจากบริการ ยี่กี่ เล่นได้ทุกวี่วัน ออกรางวัลทุก 15 นาที จ่ายแพงถึงบาทละ850 สลากกินแบ่งปิงปอง ลอตเตอรี่ป้ายประกาศผลออกทุกๆ5นาทีแต่ละวันเจ้าแรก ตลอด24ชั่วโมง รวมวันละ 288 รอบ ประเมินผลโดย Random Number มองผลกันใหม่ๆทุกวี่ทุกวัน สามารถมองผลย้อนหลังได้ จับยีกี่ที่ จ่ายมากที่สุด แทงหวยยี่กี ออนไลน์ 24 ชั่วโมง ออกดอกออกผลทุก 15 นาที วันละ 88 รอบ

  6. ลอตเตอรี่ฮานอย-เวียดนาม-vietnamสลากกินแบ่งฮานอย : เว็บไซต์แทงหวยเวียดนาม Ruay เว็บไซต์สลากกินแบ่งออนไลน์ชั้น 1 ซื้อผ่านเว็บไซต์ของพวกเราได้แล้ววันนี้ ให้บริการโดยเว็บรายใหญ่ มีโครงข่ายทั่วอาเซียน ทำให้ท่านซื้อสลากกินแบ่งได้หลายแบบ ร่ำรวยทุกวี่วัน เนื่องจากว่าเปิดให้เล่นทุกเมื่อเชื่อวันรางวัลพิเศษจาก XỔ SỐ TRUYỀN THỐNG จากประเทศเวียดนามโดยตรง